Trader Joe’s Marshmallows

I’ve dedicated this blog to in-depth, clear-eyed analysis of the strangest, most intriguing and generally hardest to fathom products Trader Joe’s brings to market. The things, in other words, that make you go “Huh – I wonder what that tastes like?”

Ranking: 5 stars 5 stars

What it is: Really good marshmallows.
Price: $2.99 for a 10 oz. bag
Worth it: Yes. Dense, sweet and creamy.
If I see, say, a can of pumpkin seed oil, or a bag of fried parsnips, I’m pretty much going to grab it immediately. That sort of stuff is irresistible to me. On the other hand, some new type of milk chocolate caramel, or whatever, is simply a bore. Without even tasting that I can tell you exactly how good it is. It’s really, really good. You don’t need me to tell you that milk chocolate and caramel taste good. Maybe  if you throw a little quinoa in there, I’d be interested. Maybe drop some pumpkin pie spice on it and I’ll perk up my ears. So why, you may be wondering, am I bothering to review something as mundane as average, unadorned, regular-old marshmallows?
Well, one – because Trader Joe’s has never carried marshmallows before. You can get muhammara, chocolate-covered potato chips and 4 different types of guac, but you’re out of luck if you want dry beans.
More importantly, however, these are the best damn marshmallows I’ve ever tasted – bar none.
Never did I dream that the standard, industrial-produced marshmallows that I have literally consumed thousands of over the course of my life – in hot chocolate, on smores, as peeps, enrobed in cheap chocolate or dusted with coconut – could be anything more than little sugary pillow of air. Never did I dream that marshmallows, by themselves, could be a delicious, craveable treat.  That’s what we’re talking about here with Trader Joe’s Maershmallows. It’s as if I’d only ever eaten garden variety Hershey bars my whole life, then someone gave me a dark chocolate bar filled with bacon-ganache. I never knew they could be this good.
Trader Joe’s Marshmallows have literally opened my eyes to the world of inferior marshmallows I have been living in. Writing that down makes me feel like the most shallow person in the world – but I’ll take my enlightenment where I can get it, thank you.
What makes these marshmallows stand out? Everything. Imagine for a moment, every enjoyable quality that an ordinary marshmallow has. Now improve them all by 200%. It’s like Trader Joe’s just brought a Lamborgini to a planet that only had go-karts.
The very first thing you’ll notice as you pick up the bag is how dense and hefty these marshmallows are. Still squishy, yes. Still malleable and yielding, but one of these marshmallows sits in the hand with the weight of three ordinary name-brand marshmallows. It’s as if Trader Joe’s decided to pump a third less air into the same quantity of marshmallow stuff.
Now take a bite. How much richier, chewier and – most notably – creamier do these Trader Joe’s Marshmallows taste? Even better, enjoy that satisfying sweetness. I’ve only never known the sugary, hit-you-in-the-bloodstream extruded corn syrup sweetness of name-brand marshmallows. Trader Joe’s marshmallows, even though they’re denser, are more mellow in their sweetness and more enjoyable to just snack on.
Yes, I said it, snack on. These marshmallows are far more than the raw ingredient for some dish topping – they’re good enough to nibble at while sitting around watching a movie. They’re more of a candy bar substitute than a marshmallow substitute.
Of course, there’s nothing stopping you from using these in place of more ordinary marshmallows in any dish. I tried making a batch of rice krispy squares, and found that not only where they waaay harder to stir, they made for a gooier, and tastier final treat. No surprise there.
There’s no doubt about it – Trader Joe’s Marshmallows deserve a rare 5-star review. They did for me what cookie butter did for me – opened my eyes to a whole new, delicious vista that I never knew existed.

The Breakdown

Would I Recommend It: Hell yeah!
Would I Buy It Again: It’s the only type of marshmallow I’ll ever by again.
Final Synopsis: The best marshmallows I’ve ever had in my whole life.

12 Comments on “Trader Joe’s Marshmallows”

  1. cheryl says:

    Wow, I love marshmallows but kinda pass them buy because of corn syrup. Can you tell me how many bad things are in there that make them so good?

    • Donna says:

      No high fructose corn syrup in these. They don’t even have gelatin. But it does have carrageenan if you are avoiding that.

      Ingredients: Tapioca syrup, can sugar, tapioca starch, carrageenan, soy protein, natural vanilla flavor.

  2. A few years ago I met a woman at the Farmers Market who made her own marshmallows, and then used them to make her own rice crispy treats (and then she dipped those in caramel, chocolate, etc. because of course she did) I’ve never been a marshmallow person, but these were literally the most amazing thing I’ve ever eaten, and like five years later I still think about them.

  3. Donna says:

    I wondered the same thing about the corn syrup. I try to stick to marshmallows that are sweetened with honey, tapioca or maple syrup.

  4. Lauren says:

    Did you make smores out of them? I am curious how the roasted up. I am going to pick up a bag for our surf/yurting trip in June and give them a try!

    • PJ says:

      Yes. They’re great for s’mores. They’re firmer than “traditional” marshmallows, so they don’t fall off the skewer/stick as easily. But they’re still gooey and squish very nicely in the s’more.

  5. Hethr says:

    I’ve found that vegan marshmallows have better flavor. Maybe they up the vanilla to make up for the lack of gelatin, but they’ve always been great. Cheaper than going to Whole foods. I hope they keep them in stock until after Thanksgiving. Personally have never had a problem roasting them.

    • Michael says:

      I’ve never really liked the flavor of regular marshmallows. After tasting the Trader Joe’s marshmallows, I thought, “wow, these are delicious!”

    • wwa says:

      I totally agree. I never liked the flavor of regular marshmallows and avoided eating them completely. Now that I’ve tasted these Trader Joe’s brand, I am in heaven. So delicious!

  6. PJ says:

    Anyone have tips for rice krispy treats? When I tried to melt these, they were still pretty thick and I wasn’t able to blend the rice krispies into them. I had to kinda mash them in.

    • Colleen says:

      I had the same issue, they are difficult to melt, if you figure it out please let me know. No matter what, they were insanely delicious. It was just difficult to get them to coat all the rice krispies.

      • Donna says:

        Marshmallows without gelatin just don’t melt as nicely. Takes a bit more elbow grease to work with them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s